Independent expertise. Entirely pub focused.Let’s talk 0330 088 3133

PUB RENT REVIEWS

Pub rent assessments: is your beer waste allowance realistic?

Check beer waste allowances in your tied pub rent assessment, understand saleable volume and see which questions to ask before agreeing the figures.

A pub cannot sell every pint it buys. When a rent proposal is built on a trading forecast, the difference between purchased volume and saleable volume deserves a careful look.

The useful question is not simply whether the forecast contains a line labelled “waste”. It is whether the calculation makes sense for the products and dispensing arrangements at your pub, and whether the resulting sales figure can be followed from start to finish.

First check which rules apply

This article concerns qualifying tied tenancies under the statutory Pubs Code in England and Wales. That regime regulates pub-owning businesses with 500 or more tied pubs and their tied tenants. It does not cover every landlord or every pub. Scotland has a separate statutory framework, so these England and Wales requirements should not be transferred to a Scottish agreement.

What should the forecast explain

For covered tenants, the PCA explains that a rent proposal or rent assessment proposal includes a 12-month profit-and-loss forecast and supporting information. The point is to understand the proposed rent, not just receive a total.

The PCA’s beer-duty and waste guidance distinguishes sediment, principally associated with cask ale, from operational waste. It calls for separate allowances rather than treating them as the same loss. Operational allowances should reflect the pub’s bar and cellar configuration, including beer lines and cleaning systems, rather than an estate-wide assumption. The benchmark is reasonably efficient operation, not acceptance of every loss a tenant actually incurs.

Ask the pub company to show how its assumptions turn purchased product into saleable quantities, revenue and gross profit. Before adding a further deduction yourself, establish whether the existing margin already incorporates it. Otherwise you can accidentally count the same loss twice.

A simple illustration

Suppose an illustrative forecast starts with 100,000 pints of purchased draught product and assumes 95,000 saleable pints. An alternative calculation produces 92,000 saleable pints. At an assumed selling price of £4 per pint excluding VAT, the difference in forecast revenue is £12,000.

Calculation: 3,000 fewer saleable pints × £4 = £12,000. These are invented teaching figures, not recommended waste percentages, a real pub’s results or an estimate of your entitlement.

That £12,000 is a revenue sensitivity, not a £12,000 rent reduction. In this deliberately simplified example, purchased quantity and purchase cost stay unchanged. A full assessment must also examine the rest of the forecast, the rental calculation and the agreement. The illustration shows why the underlying quantity matters; it does not determine the rent.

Build a short evidence file

Put the forecast beside the records that can test it. A useful working sheet has one row for each disputed assumption and four columns: the proposed figure, your question, your evidence and the response received.

For example: “The forecast assumes this annual draught sales volume. Please show the purchased volume, the waste adjustments and the selling-price calculation supporting it.” That is a more productive starting point than saying the overall rent feels too high.

Keep product invoices, stock records and till reports for matching periods. Record any material change in product range or opening pattern. Note whether a stock movement is a delivery, a return or a transfer, rather than treating everything as a sale. If your records are incomplete, identify the gap instead of disguising it with a precise-looking percentage.

Where the discussion concerns the cellar, take a dated note of the actual equipment and cleaning arrangement. Ask for an explanation you can reconcile with the pub, not simply another copy of the original spreadsheet. Keep the questions factual and retain each version of the forecast so changes can be traced.

Questions to resolve before agreeing the figures

  • Which products and volumes does the calculation include, and do the units match across the documents?
  • Where have sediment and operational losses been allowed for, and how does the forecast avoid counting either twice?
  • What evidence supports the difference between the proposed figures and the records from this pub?
  • If a volume assumption changes, which sales and profit lines change with it?
  • Which points remain disputed, and who will obtain the missing information?

Keep the wider rent review moving

A calculation query should sit alongside the rest of the review, not replace it. Check your agreement, correspondence and any approaching dates with your adviser. Do not assume that asking for further information stops a contractual or statutory timetable.

For the wider document checklist, read our pub rent review preparation guide. If you want help understanding a proposal, contact MDE Pub Consultants for an initial conversation about your pub, the documents received and any important dates. Advice is subject to a conflict check, with the scope and fees for subsequent work agreed before it begins.

General information, not advice on an individual agreement. Eligibility, obligations and procedures depend on the tenancy and circumstances. No particular rent or saving is guaranteed.

General information, not advice for a particular agreement. Rights and deadlines depend on the circumstances. If a date is approaching, obtain appropriate advice promptly.

SPECIALIST ADVICE. PERSONAL SERVICE.

Let’s talk about
your next move.

Discuss your pub, the issue you face and any important dates in a free initial conversation.

Arrange a consultation